I have always
been incredibly moved by the combination of poetry and music. This mostly takes
in a song written by various artists- The Beatles, Eagles, Weezer, and many
more. Sometimes it is the combining a poem with music in the background, which
is often done in film. Music is powerful on its own, and the combining of lyric
or poetry to a song makes something that can at times leave me speechless.
The Lighthouse Tale
The first song I
remember moving me deeply was a song written by a little folk group called
Nickel Creek. My brother had shown me their song as he was interested in
learning the mandolin, one of the main instruments in their songs. The song is
called, “The Lighthouse Tale.”
I am a lighthouse, worn by the weather and
the waves.
I keep my lamp lit, to warn the sailors on their way.
I'll tell a story, paint you a picture from my past.
I was so happy, but joy in this life seldom lasts.
I had a keeper, he helped me warn the ships at sea.
We had grown closer, 'till his joy meant everything to me.
And he was to marry, a girl who shone with beauty and light.
And they loved each other, and with me watched the sunsets into night.
I keep my lamp lit, to warn the sailors on their way.
I'll tell a story, paint you a picture from my past.
I was so happy, but joy in this life seldom lasts.
I had a keeper, he helped me warn the ships at sea.
We had grown closer, 'till his joy meant everything to me.
And he was to marry, a girl who shone with beauty and light.
And they loved each other, and with me watched the sunsets into night.
I think this was the first time I fell in love with a
story the moment I heard it. I thought it was so interesting that a lighthouse
could exist, and alongside that existence, it had feelings, emotions, things
that brought it joy and things that made it optimistic. I remember feeling
happy at the beginning, yet concerned when the lighthouse warned that “joy in
this life seldom lasts.”
She'd had to leave us, my keeper he prayed
for a safe return.
But when the night came, the weather to a raging storm had turned.
He watched her ship fight, but in vain against the wild and terrible wave.
In me so helpless, as dashed against the rock she met her end.
But when the night came, the weather to a raging storm had turned.
He watched her ship fight, but in vain against the wild and terrible wave.
In me so helpless, as dashed against the rock she met her end.
I remember this line
breaking my ten-year-old heart. I was so confused and sad. Why did she have to
leave? What was it that caused her to leave her fiancée, and why did the timing
have to be so disastrous? Could she not have waited another day at the sight of
the coming storm, or was something so urgent that required her attention that
she had to hope the storm wouldn’t affect her?
Then on the next day, my keeper found her
washed up on the shore.
He kissed her cold face, that they'd be together soon he'd swore.
I saw him crying, watched as he buried her in the sand.
And then he climbed my tower, and off of the edge of me he ran.
He kissed her cold face, that they'd be together soon he'd swore.
I saw him crying, watched as he buried her in the sand.
And then he climbed my tower, and off of the edge of me he ran.
This also brought my little
mind into a lot of confusion. I didn’t understand why the keeper had to commit
suicide. I understood that he loved her, and that her loss was a lot for him to
take him, but did he not have any other things in his life to fight for? His
faith, or his family, or the lighthouse itself? Was the lighthouse’s love
returned to him through the keeper, or did the keeper only care for the girl? I
felt that it was foolish for me to judge the keeper. I didn’t know what he had
in his life. I have never myself, then or now, experienced anything close to
the heartbreak that revolves around death, and especially the death of a spouse
(or future spouse). To this day I try to keep that mindset of not judging
others, especially when it comes to things I haven’t been close to
experiencing.
I am a lighthouse, worn by the weather and
the waves.
And though I am empty, I still warn the sailors on their way.
And though I am empty, I still warn the sailors on their way.
I was happy with the way it ended. Although the lighthouse
had little to hold on to in life, it stayed true to its promise of watching
over the sea. I was hopeful in thinking that the lighthouse would learn to love
again, as another keeper would most likely find their way to the lighthouse. I hoped
that the lighthouse would be okay with the new story and experiences that
another keeper would bring.
Good Timber
Poetry set to music is amazing. Sometimes, however, a poem
can have just as much power when it is read by a single speaker, with nothing
but silence filling the gaps of his reading. I felt this power when I heard a
poem read by President Thomas S. Monson, prophet of the Church of Jesus Christ
of Latter-Day Saints. He was speaking about not giving up, and despite the
inevitable trials that will come in life, we can become something greater when
we take everything in stride. He related this topic to the poem “Good Timer”
written by Douglas Malloch.
Good
timber does not grow with ease,
The
stronger wind, the stronger trees.
The
further sky, the greater length.
The
more the storm, the more the strength.
By
sun and cold, by rain and snow,
In
trees and men good timbers grow
This poem has meant a lot to
me as I’ve grown over the years. I have had to learn a lot of lessons in life
the hard way. I have made mistakes that put me in situations I would rather not
be in. I feel like life has two ways of putting you in storms; either life
throws a storm at you, out of nowhere, and there was nothing you could have
done to avoid it, or there are storms that you put yourself in because of negligence.
I cannot speak too much about the former. I have been lucky in my life when it
comes to random storms. While I do believe that people can overcome any trial
that life throws at them (the untimely death of a family member, being fired,
becoming sick), I simply cannot speak about those kind of storms through
experience. However, I can very much relate to the latter.
I have heard through the
Bible, Book of Mormon, and leaders of the church, that you cannot sin
intentionally and say that you will repent later. For a long time, I didn’t understand
that. I could think of numerous people and stories where they intentionally did
something wrong due to their want or greed or lust. Later they sincerely repent
and life goes on. I have been that person, many times… and I am lucky. I have
seen others who do sin and find themselves on a very slippery slope. They put
themselves in a storm, and sometimes, that storm is simply too strong that it
does not reinforce the bark or strengthen the roots, but it destroys the tree.
When you put yourself in these
kind of storms, you face a different kind of storm. Can you be strong enough to
fight it? Or will the storm take you?
This poem has helped me to
understand that, in the first kind of storm, I can face it and I will come out
on the other side. My friends will be there. My family will be there. God will
be there. With the other kind of storms, I don’t have as strong of a promise.
So I want to live my life so that I will not find myself in the second kind of
storms- and when the first kind of storms come, I will be ready, and good,
stronger tress will grow.
Song lyrics can be extremely moving poetry. I have never heard of the first song that you mentioned but now I want to look it up! Just a few thoughts about your essay:
ReplyDeleteI loved the feelings that you shared in both poems but, I'm afraid you might need more analysis. Speak on word choice or the personification of the lighthouse. Show us what you know!
Give us something to look at! A picture of some sort!
I feel like the choice of two poems was risky but it can be successful if done right. Maybe share more of your personal experience with "storms" while you discuss the lighthouse? Find some way to connect your two poems. You've got a great start! Also-I have no idea who wrote this. Make sure to use those lovely labels!
I don't want to call this a negative on your post because it might just be personal taste for me, but I kind of wish you had stuck to just one work. I loved your analysis and connection with the first part, the song. If you had written your whole post on just that song, and gone deeper into your analysis, I think it would be stronger. Or do your whole post on the second if you have more to say about that one. Again, that might just be one person's humble opinion! And your analysis for both works was very good. Very personal and analytical at the same time. Well done!
ReplyDeleteI really loved the personal experiences behind both of these poems its obvious that you have genuine feelings about this song "the lighthouse". I felt like it was also broken up really well I liked your style of putting in a section or two of the song and then pausing to explain what it means to you and how you saw it through your ten year old eyes. I do agree that you should add some more analysis of the song in there though and expand a little bit more on the style of the poetry and why the writer did what they chose to do.
ReplyDelete